Why AI copy makes up your numbers, and the three checks that stop it
The brief said live classes at 6:30 am. The ad came back saying 20 minutes a day. Nobody gave a 20.
The check passed it. The number sat there looking earned, and it fit the rhythm of the line.
The pattern I see in my log
A piece has a shape, and the shape has slots. An ad wants a number: how long, how much, how many. A landing page wants a price. A video script wants a result. The slots are part of the form; the reader expects them. When the brief leaves a slot empty, the writer fills it. With general AI copy, the writer fills it with whatever fits, and nothing flags it as a guess.
My failure log holds 55 entries, and this pattern keeps coming back in it.
Three more cases
The brief said under 250 pounds. The headline came back with a dollar sign in front of 250. The currency was wrong; the number looked right; the slot was filled.
Three pieces came back with a blank in square brackets where a clinic name, a sender name and a booking link belonged. That is the visible failure, and it is easy to fix. The invisible failure is worse: a number that looks as if it came from you.
My own dictated brief for a 60-second script came back, on an earlier version of this tool, with a shot list and a price nobody had stated. I had given neither. The tool had a slot for each and it filled them.
Why a simple check misses these
The 20-minutes case passed the first check I ran. The check pulled 6 and 30 from the clock time in the brief and counted 20 as a sum of them. It saw a number, found two numbers that could account for it and passed the line. The dollar sign on 250 pounds passed because 250 was in the request; the check found the number and stopped there. A check that looks only for the number is too weak. It has to read the money sign and where the number came from as well.
Check one: lock the facts before the writing
The brief is read into a spec before a word of copy is written. The spec holds the order, the facts, the offer and what I said to leave out. A number that enters the copy has to be in the spec first.
Check two: read every claim against the spec
After the writing, every number, every money sign and every promise in the piece is read against the spec. If a claim has no fact behind it, it comes out. Today the 20 comes out. The dollar sign comes out. The price nobody stated comes out before you see it.
Check three: name the missing fact in one line
A fact the piece needs and the brief did not give is named in one line. The piece still arrives, written around the gap. The missing fact is handed back so you can supply it or cut the line. This is the step the square-bracket cases needed: today the clinic name, the sender name and the booking link are named as open items, and the copy is written around them.
What the log holds
My log holds 55 failures today. The 20-minutes case is in it. The dollar sign on 250 pounds is in it. The shot list and the price nobody stated are in it. Each one is kept as a test.
What Copy Desk does
Copy Desk runs these three checks on every piece it writes. It reads your brief into a spec, reads every claim against your facts after the writing, and names any fact it is missing. Every number in your copy comes from you.